web site hit counter When Abortion Was a Crime: Women, Medicine, and Law in the United States, 1867-1973 - Ebooks PDF Online
Hot Best Seller

When Abortion Was a Crime: Women, Medicine, and Law in the United States, 1867-1973

Availability: Ready to download

As we approach the 30th anniversary of Roe v. Wade, it's crucial to look back to the time when abortion was illegal. Leslie Reagan traces the practice and policing of abortion, which although illegal was nonetheless widely available, but always with threats for both doctor and patient. In a time when many young women don't even know that there was a period when abortion wa As we approach the 30th anniversary of Roe v. Wade, it's crucial to look back to the time when abortion was illegal. Leslie Reagan traces the practice and policing of abortion, which although illegal was nonetheless widely available, but always with threats for both doctor and patient. In a time when many young women don't even know that there was a period when abortion was a crime, this work offers chilling and vital lessons of importance to everyone. The linking of the words "abortion" and "crime" emphasizes the difficult and painful history that is the focus of Leslie J. Reagan's important book. Her study is the first to examine the entire period during which abortion was illegal in the United States, beginning in the mid-nineteenth century and ending with Roe v. Wade in 1973. Although illegal, millions of abortions were provided during these years to women of every class, race, and marital status. The experiences and perspectives of these women, as well as their physicians and midwives, are movingly portrayed here. Reagan traces the practice and policing of abortion. While abortions have been typically portrayed as grim "back alley" operations, she finds that abortion providers often practiced openly and safely. Moreover, numerous physicians performed abortions, despite prohibitions by the state and the American Medical Association. Women often found cooperative practioners, but prosecution, public humiliation, loss of privacy, and inferior medical care were a constant threat. Reagan's analysis of previously untapped sources, including inquest records and trial transcripts, shows the fragility of patient rights and raises provocative questions about the relationship between medicine and law. With the right to abortion again under attack in the United States, this book offers vital lessons for every American concerned with health care, civil liberties, and personal and sexual freedom.


Compare

As we approach the 30th anniversary of Roe v. Wade, it's crucial to look back to the time when abortion was illegal. Leslie Reagan traces the practice and policing of abortion, which although illegal was nonetheless widely available, but always with threats for both doctor and patient. In a time when many young women don't even know that there was a period when abortion wa As we approach the 30th anniversary of Roe v. Wade, it's crucial to look back to the time when abortion was illegal. Leslie Reagan traces the practice and policing of abortion, which although illegal was nonetheless widely available, but always with threats for both doctor and patient. In a time when many young women don't even know that there was a period when abortion was a crime, this work offers chilling and vital lessons of importance to everyone. The linking of the words "abortion" and "crime" emphasizes the difficult and painful history that is the focus of Leslie J. Reagan's important book. Her study is the first to examine the entire period during which abortion was illegal in the United States, beginning in the mid-nineteenth century and ending with Roe v. Wade in 1973. Although illegal, millions of abortions were provided during these years to women of every class, race, and marital status. The experiences and perspectives of these women, as well as their physicians and midwives, are movingly portrayed here. Reagan traces the practice and policing of abortion. While abortions have been typically portrayed as grim "back alley" operations, she finds that abortion providers often practiced openly and safely. Moreover, numerous physicians performed abortions, despite prohibitions by the state and the American Medical Association. Women often found cooperative practioners, but prosecution, public humiliation, loss of privacy, and inferior medical care were a constant threat. Reagan's analysis of previously untapped sources, including inquest records and trial transcripts, shows the fragility of patient rights and raises provocative questions about the relationship between medicine and law. With the right to abortion again under attack in the United States, this book offers vital lessons for every American concerned with health care, civil liberties, and personal and sexual freedom.

30 review for When Abortion Was a Crime: Women, Medicine, and Law in the United States, 1867-1973

  1. 5 out of 5

    Keith Schnell

    There are several things that make this book stand out: its unique subject matter, its overall tone and the high quality of original research that obviously went into it. When Abortion was a Crime deals with the period of just over 100 years when abortion was prohibited by law in most circumstances in the United States. This is something that, surprisingly, has seldom been explored in detail, which is unfortunate given the continued and quixotic efforts of so many state legislatures to return th There are several things that make this book stand out: its unique subject matter, its overall tone and the high quality of original research that obviously went into it. When Abortion was a Crime deals with the period of just over 100 years when abortion was prohibited by law in most circumstances in the United States. This is something that, surprisingly, has seldom been explored in detail, which is unfortunate given the continued and quixotic efforts of so many state legislatures to return the United States to that time. It is almost as if we are endlessly arguing about whether or not to ban alcohol without ever remembering what happened when we tried. This book goes a long way towards correcting that. Dr. Reagan approaches the subject with a very professional tone, which should be expected in a work of history but stands out given the politically charged subject matter. All too often, in publications such as The Huffington Post and Salon, the point of an article about abortion is to drum up outrage and, implicitly, money and votes, such that even those who are “pro-choice” must feel disturbingly like they are reading their own side’s shrill propaganda. When Abortion was a Crime avoids this trap, instead dispassionately documenting, in great detail, the abuses brought on by restrictive abortion laws prior to 1973. The author seems to feel that her readers are intelligent enough that she can let the facts speak for themselves, and they certainly do. Lastly, I would be in remiss if I failed to mention the work that Dr. Reagan has done in bringing to light primary sources such as court cases, witness testimonies and 19th century newspapers describing the ways in which abortion laws were enforced. This 400-page book contains nearly 150 pages of endnotes, many of which are fascinating in their own right and do a great deal to reinforce the text. The only weak spot in this book is in the epilogue. Having produced several hundred pages of excellent historical documentation of the era 1867-1973, the author seems compelled by her passion for the subject matter to discuss developments since Roe v. Wade. She is unable to do so thoroughly in the ten pages that she has given it. As much as one would like to give her the benefit of the doubt given her evident expertise, the epilogue lacks the thorough exposition and supporting detail that is due of a complex subject. It is a shame that she did not produce a second volume dealing with developments after 1973, which would have been necessary to do the subject justice. Ultimately, though, the failure to adequately examine restrictions and court cases subsequent to Roe v. Wade does not take away from the fundamental and inescapable conclusion of When Abortion was a Crime. Restrictive abortion laws prior to 1973, which banned the procedure in almost all circumstances, were a public policy disaster on par with Prohibition. The abuses that they inflicted on women, doctors, and, in some cases, even men were remarkably brutal and would simply not be accepted in the more free and civilized society of 21st Century America. As those who were adults during this period gradually die off, it is important that we retain this understanding, and Dr. Reagan’s book is an essential tool in doing so.

  2. 4 out of 5

    Lauriann

    Great feminist read. It really helped me understand the arguments behind legalizing abortion much better. This book also also changed my perceptions about women, sexuality, motherhood, and the pervasiveness of abortion in the past.

  3. 4 out of 5

    Lindsay

    The demand for abortion has always existed and has never waned, but has experienced varying degrees of criminality, legality, and stigma. Reagan's book is testament to the hard truth that abortion has and always will be needed and is a fundamental reproductive right. One of the few books chronicling the long period of illegal abortion in the United States, this book is a well-researched, vital resource for understanding the public and private history of abortion. Using information from doctors, The demand for abortion has always existed and has never waned, but has experienced varying degrees of criminality, legality, and stigma. Reagan's book is testament to the hard truth that abortion has and always will be needed and is a fundamental reproductive right. One of the few books chronicling the long period of illegal abortion in the United States, this book is a well-researched, vital resource for understanding the public and private history of abortion. Using information from doctors, medical associations, legal records, hospital records, and whenever possible, women themselves, Reagan pieces together a landscape of access or lack thereof combined with cultural context and public opinion. Unfortunately, the century before Roe v. Wade doesn't sound all that unfamiliar given the current political climate surrounding abortion. Then, as now, public discourse often centered around a white patriarchy, bogged down in social constricts and dogma, making decisions for women across the country, despite a huge rate of abortion deaths, entire wards dedicated to women healing from illegal abortions, and the clear demand for abortion and obvious reality that women would go to any length necessary to control their reproduction. However, the author does not gloss over the often unspoken reality of compassionate personal relationships between doctor and patient, with many physicians behaving sympathetically toward their abortion-seeking patients and doing what they could to help at personal risk. The attention paid to midwives, who often served immigrant women of their own ethnicity, is particularly interesting, both in its study of their vilification and of the much needed services they provided to their communities. As now, media at all times throughout the century highlighted only the negative outcomes of abortion care, and the fact that for many decades the only archived information about abortion comes from legal proceedings against women, midwives, and physicians, is telling. As midwives and doulas are again organizing on the grassroots level to provide abortion care for women, their stories from the past can provide lessons for our current struggle for access. Glaringly absent until the final chapters, by the author's own admission, are stories from women of color, and less glaring, low-income women, seeking abortion care. This spotlights the inequality of medical care and concern towards these women still prevalent today, as lack of access as well as lack of attention are indicative of the attitudes of, again, a white patriarchal system combined with white upper and middle class women's groups. To be fair, many of these women's groups sought to correct their attitudes. The lessons of the early women's liberation movement, where women of color increasingly refused to be invisible and demanded attention on their own terms, feel familiar, and it is a mistake to think that we don't still have far to go on that front. While the book ends on a somewhat positive tone, focusing on the legalization of abortion with Roe v. Wade, it seems fitting to end this review with a quote from the epilogue that asks us to look backward and fight against the misguided efforts of the anti-choice to return us to the time when abortion was a crime: "If abortion is made illegal, some women will die; many more will be injured. The old abortion wards will have to be reopened, a public health disaster recreated. Making abortion hard to obtain will not return the United States to an imagined time of virginal brides and stable families; it will return us to the time of crowded septic abortion wards, avoidable deaths, and the routinization of punitive treatment of women by state authorities and their surrogates."

  4. 5 out of 5

    Brad Hart

    This was an excellent look into the history of abortion. Reagan successfully debunks a number of the myths surrounding the history of abortion, and illustrates how abortion in recent years has distorted the truth regarding its past. An excellent and well-balanced book.

  5. 4 out of 5

    Marla McMackin

    Leslie J. Reagan’s When Abortion Was a Crime is the first study of the entire period of illegal abortion in the United States. Over eight chapters, Reagan examines “the triangle of interactions among the medical profession, state authorities, and women in the practice, policing, and politics of abortion during the era when abortion was a crime” (p. 1). The result is a multifaceted analysis of the still controversial medical procedure that connects the experiences of women and local medical and l Leslie J. Reagan’s When Abortion Was a Crime is the first study of the entire period of illegal abortion in the United States. Over eight chapters, Reagan examines “the triangle of interactions among the medical profession, state authorities, and women in the practice, policing, and politics of abortion during the era when abortion was a crime” (p. 1). The result is a multifaceted analysis of the still controversial medical procedure that connects the experiences of women and local medical and legal practice to national policy. Reagan divides the era of illegal abortion into four periods, which establish the structure of her work. The first, and focus of the first four chapters, begins in the late nineteenth century, when laws passed across the country between 1860 and 1880 prohibited abortion at any point during pregnancy. Each of the four chapters covers a different aspect of abortion through the 1920s – women’s experiences with the procedure, its practice, and political and law enforcement reactions. Reagan argues that despite the ban, abortion was widely accepted and practiced in women’s homes and the offices of both midwives and trained physicians. The prevalence of abortion was possible not only because of this diversity of practitioners, but also because the practice of medicine remained private. Yet, a crackdown on abortion occurred during the same period as specialists in the developing field of obstetrics renewed an earlier campaign against the practice and the medical profession was drawn into the state’s enforcement system. The second half of Reagan’s work covers the next three periods in a more chronological history of abortion. During the 1930s, economic hardships of the Great Depression led to an expansion of the practice. Trained physicians were more willing to offer “therapeutic” abortions based on social conditions and the practice not only became more widely available, but also moved from private homes to hospitals and clinics. According to Reagan, abortion was a recurring and common need for many women. In 1936, New Jersey police uncovered a “Birth Control Club” of eight hundred members who were entitled to regular examinations and abortions for an additional $75. “These working women bought a form of health insurance through dues paid to this ‘club.’ These women expected to have abortions in the future. The club provided a means of blunting the expense” (p. 134). Although the consolidation of the practice in the hands of trained physicians might have benefitted some women who sought abortions in the 1930s, Reagan asserts the increased visibility accelerated the pace of change in the following decades, especially in the methods of enforcing criminal abortion laws. The third period begins in 1940, with a backlash against the previous decade’s expansion of abortion. Hospitals adopted a more conservative stance, while police and prosecutors adopted new tactics. Prosecutors no longer focused on abortionists responsible for women’s deaths, instead working “to shut down the trusted and skilled abortionists, many of them physicians, who had operated clinics for years with little or no police interference…This system had created a space in which thousands of women obtained safe abortions from skilled physicians in an environment nearly identical to that of any other medical practice” (p. 161). The women were also at increased risk of being victimized by prosecutors, who could force them to testify about their sexual activity in open court, and by police, who according to Reagan would go so far as to capture women and invade their bodies to investigate illegal abortion. In December 1947, a woman picked up by police in Chicago while leaving the apartment of a midwife was taken to a doctor’s office. Once there, Clara L. “‘submitted’ to a gynecological exam performed by Dr. Janet Towne in the presence of a policewoman. Dr. Towne examined Clara L., determined she was pregnant, and then removed a rubber catheter placed in the cervix” (p. 168) to induce the abortion. Reagan argues that the intensified repression, and an increased demand for the procedure from women of all groups, resulted in a system divided by race and class. It continued with devastating results until methods of suppressing abortion were finally dismantled. The fourth and final period overlaps with the third and concludes with the 1973 Supreme Court decision in Roe vs. Wade. The movement to decriminalize abortion that developed in this period was in reaction to a system that had fatal consequences for many women. Reagan asserts that during the 1950s, a handful of physicians began to challenge the laws their profession had advocated a century earlier and the progress of that challenge attests to the continuing power of the medical profession to make public policy regarding reproduction. Additionally, as legal reform moved forward, a new feminist movement arose, which radically transformed the movement for legal change. “When the women’s movement described abortion as an aspect of sexual freedom, they articulated a new feminist meaning for abortion; when they demanded abortion as a right, they echoed generations of women” (p. 15-16). Reagan employs a rich array of primary source material to develop her analysis, including criminal trial and other legal records, medical literature, government documents, newspapers, popular periodicals, hospital records and manuscript collections. In being the first to chart the nation’s enforcement of criminal abortion laws, Reagan gives ample attention to the state’s interest in suppressing the practice and the its alliance with the medical community. She uncovers the circumstances of actual abortions, revealing changing practices and the risks women have been willing to take to assume their reproductive rights. Reagan also effectively argues that the antiabortion campaign was antifeminist at its core, with efforts to restrict or reverse abortion rights sending a clear message that “women cannot be trusted to make moral decisions about children and family, but must be overseen and regulated by men; procreation is a state mandate not a choice; women’s lives, sexuality, and bodies are not their own” (p. 253).

  6. 5 out of 5

    Liza Connolly (Hinkle)

    This is an academic text chronicling the history of abortion during the ~100 years it was illegal in the United States ending in 1973. It draws upon primary sources to paint as accurate a picture as we can get of the underground reality of abortion during this time period. It also illustrates how the intersection of law, public opinion, medicine, religion, and enforcement interacted with this reality in different ways over the years. I learned a lot from this book, and I had thought I was decent This is an academic text chronicling the history of abortion during the ~100 years it was illegal in the United States ending in 1973. It draws upon primary sources to paint as accurate a picture as we can get of the underground reality of abortion during this time period. It also illustrates how the intersection of law, public opinion, medicine, religion, and enforcement interacted with this reality in different ways over the years. I learned a lot from this book, and I had thought I was decently literate on the topic to begin with. In case you ever wondered why and how the midwife profession went away, or thought perhaps abortion was a recent issue, or wanted to know about the entire hospital wards dedicated to treating women who took matters into their own hands… this book may be for you. It’s dense though, and a little repetitive, so read it in chunks. It’s important to know history, lest we be doomed to repeat it. While this text is not a work of opinion, the implications of this history are still clear to me. 4.5 stars.

  7. 4 out of 5

    Deirdre

    This is a very detailed history of the 100+ years that abortion was a crime in the USA. I had previously read another book on the subject and I felt the author was biased and her personal opinions kept peeking through, not the case with Leslie J. Reagan. I appreciated the facts without the opinion mixed in. I also loved the seriously detailed references she included. I came away from this book with a deeper understanding of this controversial subject.I would definitely recommend it to others who This is a very detailed history of the 100+ years that abortion was a crime in the USA. I had previously read another book on the subject and I felt the author was biased and her personal opinions kept peeking through, not the case with Leslie J. Reagan. I appreciated the facts without the opinion mixed in. I also loved the seriously detailed references she included. I came away from this book with a deeper understanding of this controversial subject.I would definitely recommend it to others who want to know more about the history of Abortion.

  8. 5 out of 5

    Lisa

    I admit I did not finish this book (I read all but the last chapter). It was literally giving me nightmares. Without getting too politic-y, I'm a pro-choice Democrat, but I don't think I would personally choose abortion. I have felt for a long time that if abortion would be criminalized, there would be serious consequences, and this book and its thorough research bears that out. Very interesting, if horrifying. I admit I did not finish this book (I read all but the last chapter). It was literally giving me nightmares. Without getting too politic-y, I'm a pro-choice Democrat, but I don't think I would personally choose abortion. I have felt for a long time that if abortion would be criminalized, there would be serious consequences, and this book and its thorough research bears that out. Very interesting, if horrifying.

  9. 4 out of 5

    Ericka

    Solid. Academic. Very thin, theoretically speaking. What analysis there was felt dated. You’d need a particular interest in the topic, because the writing itself is not compelling.

  10. 4 out of 5

    L**

    An exciting, well researched look into the history of abortion in the US. Reagan examines the interaction of women, doctors, and social/ cultural/ political/ religious leaders over 106 years in which abortion was illegal in every state. Her focus on Chicago provides an interesting window into the sexual and reproductive politics in a growing and diversifying industrial urban center. Reagan finds that enforcement of the law and prosecution of those who defied the law varied over time. The Depress An exciting, well researched look into the history of abortion in the US. Reagan examines the interaction of women, doctors, and social/ cultural/ political/ religious leaders over 106 years in which abortion was illegal in every state. Her focus on Chicago provides an interesting window into the sexual and reproductive politics in a growing and diversifying industrial urban center. Reagan finds that enforcement of the law and prosecution of those who defied the law varied over time. The Depression, for example,was a period in which enforcement was particularly lax, as more people saw abortion as the desperate act of impoverished women and not the immoral act of a sinner, as 19th century critics framed it. What is consistent, she notes, is that making abortion illegal does not stop women from wanting, needing, or seeking it. It makes harder and infinitely more dangerous for the women who have them and creates a division between women with means (who often could find ways to have fairly safe abortions) and those without (who were often exploited by charlatans and unscrupulous people at enormous risk). Turning the tide in the 1960s to strike down anti-abortion laws came from a range of perspectives, much as the 1800s activism to make abortion crime had. As anti-abortion activism continues in the US, this book is a powerful reminder that regardless of the law, women will have abortions, and the reasons a woman does have them are unique, meaningful, and personal to her. Whether a woman seeks abortion because of devastating fetal defects, poverty, or the pregnancy is the unwanted outcome of birth control failure, millions of woman want to control their bodies and reproductive lives-- even when an illegal abortion means risking their own.

  11. 4 out of 5

    M. Benesh

    This book both explores the history of illegal abortion and, in doing so, simultaneously creates a compelling case for its continued legalization. I think it would be impossible to read this book and remain convinced that abortion is anything but a necessary human right, and Reagan also frames this right as central to protecting patient autonomy over their health and bodies. Most shocking about this history are the different reasons why abortion became increasingly regulated over the years-- I pe This book both explores the history of illegal abortion and, in doing so, simultaneously creates a compelling case for its continued legalization. I think it would be impossible to read this book and remain convinced that abortion is anything but a necessary human right, and Reagan also frames this right as central to protecting patient autonomy over their health and bodies. Most shocking about this history are the different reasons why abortion became increasingly regulated over the years-- I personally thought the narrative of "human being since conception" had a longer history, but it is a relatively recent moral argument. As a whole, this book really influenced my thinking on this topic, despite my original opinions. I hope this book is widely read.

  12. 5 out of 5

    Aja

    Super interesting look at the 100 + years that abortion was officially illegal. I think that the biggest surprise was in regards to public opinion during the first 50 or so years of illegality, when the law did not match the general public opinion of abortion. Intro and Epilogue are very obviously written from one particular side of the story, but the bulk of the book is quite fair in telling the facts of this time period.

  13. 4 out of 5

    Cheryl

    I found it sad and discouraging that in all cases where a change in the laws and procedures occurred, women’s voices were silent. Women’s experiences and lives were completely discounted and ignored. Only after Roe did we start to find our voices… but we still have so far to go. A good and thorough history of an underground and basically undocumented American experience.

  14. 5 out of 5

    Robyn

    This book contains in-depth research into the statutory, regulatory, and professional practice barriers to abortion prior to Roe V Wade and Doe v Bolton. Reagan's analysis is directly relevant to today's climate surrounding abortion. The restrictions that we see today are an extension to pass efforts to control access to reproductive health services. This book contains in-depth research into the statutory, regulatory, and professional practice barriers to abortion prior to Roe V Wade and Doe v Bolton. Reagan's analysis is directly relevant to today's climate surrounding abortion. The restrictions that we see today are an extension to pass efforts to control access to reproductive health services.

  15. 4 out of 5

    Anna

    Kind of dry at times, but an IMPORTANT read that gets to the heart of why abortion access restrictions, overturning Roe v. Wade are so terrifying. This is probably one of the best books about the history of abortion I've read. Kind of dry at times, but an IMPORTANT read that gets to the heart of why abortion access restrictions, overturning Roe v. Wade are so terrifying. This is probably one of the best books about the history of abortion I've read.

  16. 5 out of 5

    Austin

    "the legalization of abortion represented an improvement in maternal mortality that ranks with the invention of antisepsis and antibiotics" "the legalization of abortion represented an improvement in maternal mortality that ranks with the invention of antisepsis and antibiotics"

  17. 4 out of 5

    Anayim

    An amazing history of how abortion has evolved through the years, and such great evidence of why abortion is so crucial to our society today.

  18. 5 out of 5

    Wealhtheow

    I'm really interested in Reagan's assertion that the German Measles epidemic in the 1960s played a role in legalizing abortion. http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_release... I'm really interested in Reagan's assertion that the German Measles epidemic in the 1960s played a role in legalizing abortion. http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_release...

  19. 5 out of 5

    Kat

    This book took me a LONG TIME, because it is not an easy read! The second half is a bit smoother than the first, but even so, it is a thorough historical text. It is a worthwhile one, though, especially with its focus on Chicago history and its, well, familiarity with the present day. It was written in 1997, but things truly haven’t changed much (except for the worse). I think Reagan did a decent job of acknowledging the movement led by non-white women, but I wish she had centered them more, par This book took me a LONG TIME, because it is not an easy read! The second half is a bit smoother than the first, but even so, it is a thorough historical text. It is a worthwhile one, though, especially with its focus on Chicago history and its, well, familiarity with the present day. It was written in 1997, but things truly haven’t changed much (except for the worse). I think Reagan did a decent job of acknowledging the movement led by non-white women, but I wish she had centered them more, particularly in the chapters about 1950 and beyond.

  20. 5 out of 5

    Радостин Марчев

    Аз имам проблем с някои от заключенията на автора, но документалните изследвания, които е събрал са забележителни. като цяло много полезна книга за всеки, който желае да навлезе в историческата фактология.

  21. 5 out of 5

    Irene Wight

    Informative I had no idea how abortions throughout history were looked upon. Outlawing it doesn’t stop it! How can people be against it and also be against social programs that can help once the baby is born. That includes free healthcare, education etc..

  22. 4 out of 5

    John

    Exceptionally well explored, researched, and conveyed. This added an incredible amount of history and context to my understanding of abortion access.

  23. 4 out of 5

    Kye Flannery

    nourishing, profound, precise, ennobling, crushing, magnificent.

  24. 4 out of 5

    Glenda

    See highlights for interesting trivia, phrases, wording and facts !!

  25. 4 out of 5

    Siskiyou-Suzy

    I bought this book in a fit of feminism and read the whole thing even though it was, at times, terribly boring. There are old newspapers in it though, and I love me some old newspapers.

  26. 4 out of 5

    Branwyn Lewis

  27. 5 out of 5

    Lindsey

  28. 5 out of 5

    Cassandra

  29. 4 out of 5

    Chester

  30. 4 out of 5

    Saad

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Loading...